Alpha Pack Summit Book Extra Content Contact Us
FREE CASE STUDY

AGENCY CONTEST

 We ran a head‑to‑head agency contest with top agencies to find out which product images truly capture attention and drive clicks. Amazon sellers submitted their product visuals for testing, and we tracked how real buyers reacted. The results will surprise you, and teach you what works (and what doesn’t) when selling on Amazon

 

 

Who is ProductPinion

ProductPinion is an award winning shopper insights and A/B testing platform built specifically for Amazon sellers like you. It helps you validate product ideas, optimize your listings, and uncover what drives clicks and conversions by gathering fast feedback from real Amazon shoppers. You can watch real people shop your listings, run true search simulations, and target audiences using 215 advanced traits with no extra costs. All powered by the largest global panel of verified shoppers.

Want to test creatives creatives for your own brand? Visit www.productpinion.com for a free 7 day trial and get 20 shoppers opinions for free. 

What Was Tested

We tested main images, secondary images, and A+ content to see what grabbed attention. Each agency was given the same brief and product information, creating a real‑world comparison of creative approaches.

 Who the Agencies Are

  1. Mad Lemon Media
  2. AMZ One Step
  3. Ecomcy
  4. Mindful Goods
  5. Maxamaze

MAD LEMON MEDIA

 

At Mad Lemon Media, our tailored suite of creative assets is designed to make your products irresistible to shoppers, propelling your sales to new heights.

 
 
Services: 

Product Photography

Product Video

Hero Image Optimization

Main Image Stack

 

A+ Content

 

 

 

Offer: 10% off 

Discount Code: Mention TOP DOG

 

 

AMZ ONE STEP

 

AMZ One Step is a creative agency and PPC management company that specializes in helping Amazon brands grow by improving two of the most important metrics: click-through rate (CTR) and conversion rate (CVR).

 

Website: https://www.amzonestep.com/

 

Services:

Product Photography

Product Videography

A+ Content

PPC management 

 

 

Offer: 10% off 

Discount Code: Mention TOP DOG

 

ECOMCY

 

Ecomcy is a full-service agency specializing in driving growth and scaling brands on Amazon, Walmart, and TikTok. With a deep understanding of e-commerce and digital marketing, Ecomcy helps businesses optimize their presence across major retail platforms by providing comprehensive services, including strategic advertising, listing optimization, data-driven insights, and content creation.

 

Website: https://www.ecomcy.com/ 

Services:

Amazon and Walmart store setup

and management

Data analytics

and reporting

PPC campaign management

and optimization

DSP and external

traffic strategies

Product listing optimization

and A+ content creation

Amazon Marketing Cloud

(AMC) integrations

TikTok marketing and

influencer collaborations

 

  

Offer: 20% Off

Discount Code: TopDog20

 

MINDFUL GOODS

 

MindfulGoods.co is the go-to creative studio for Amazon brands. As a featured speaker at Amazon Accelerate 2024, they are a leading expert in Amazon optimization supporting hundreds of eCommerce brands to double and triple their sales on Amazon with creative content that converts. 

 

Website: https://mindfulgoods.co/showcase

Services:

Amazon Listing

Optimization

Amazon Premium

A+ Content EBC

Amazon Product

Images

Amazon Launch

Packs

UGC Video

3-Pack

Amazon Photoshoot

Add-On

AI for Large

Catalog Scaling

 

 

Offer: $300 off any package

Discount code: FLOWVIP 
 

 

MAXAMAZE

 

We harness the power of showstopping creatives, combined with our in-depth understanding of the inner workings of the platform, to help you build and grow your brand presence, sales and profits. From product photography and videos to A+ content and storefront design, we are your one-stop solution.

 

Website: https://www.maxamaze.co/

Services:

Keyword Research

SEO Titles

Main Images

Lifestyle Images

Product Videos

A+ Content

  

Offer: 10% off + free 30-minute listing audit call

Discount code: Mention TOP DOG
 

 

The Big Reveal

 

Results & Voting Process

After running each agency’s creative through ProductPinion’s ranked testing system, real Amazon shoppers were asked to vote on their top picks, from main images to secondary images and A+ content.

 

MAIN IMAGE

Mad Lemon Media

1st Place

Mindful Goods

 2nd Place

AMZOneStep

 3rd Place

 

SECONDARY IMAGE

Mad Lemon Media

 1st Place

MaxAmaze

 2nd Place

Mindful Goods

 3rd Place

 

A+ CONTENT

Ecomcy

 1st Place

AMZOneStep

 2nd Place

Mindful Goods

 3rd Place

 

Overall Winners

Mad Lemon Media

12 points

Mindful Goods

10 points

Ecomcy / MaxAmaze / AMZOneStep

 7 points

Mess Less

 30-Day Challenge

 

Join our free challenge. Take FLOW and RESTORE daily and master your mind, your time & your habits in 30 Days.

Daily lessons on mindset, focus, calendar mastery, business autopilot, systems, and success habits. Sharpen your productivity edge — one day at a time.

Learn more →

Mess Less

 30-Day Challenge

 

Join our free challenge. Take FLOW and RESTORE daily and master your mind, your time & your habits in 30 Days.

Daily lessons on mindset, focus, calendar mastery, business autopilot, systems, and success habits. Sharpen your productivity edge — one day at a time.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Learn more →